Advanced technique · Chains · 06

AIC

Alternating Inference Chains connect strong and weak links into an endpoint proof.

AdvancedChainsElimination

The idea

ALTERNATING INFERENCE CHAINS GENERALIZE THE CHAIN IDEA.

An Alternating Inference Chain (AIC) uses alternating strong and weak links with multiple numbers. The idea lets you move beyond one-number chains such as X-Chain or simple bivalue patterns such as XY-Chain. Similar to X-Chain and XY-Chain, an AIC is open ended.

Elimination: An AIC eliminates the target number in a cell that sees both ends of the AIC where both end cells contain the target number.

The question: Can multi-candidates links alternate all the way from one strong endpoint to another?

Walkthroughs

READ THE CHAIN AS A PROOF

No need to memorize chain shapes. Start with the multi-candidates links: strong, weak, strong, weak. Then follow the implications and inspect what the endpoints prove.

Walkthrough

Example 01 — Controdication

A six cells multi-number open ended chain is illustrated below with green strong links and yellow weak links. The chain starts from cell r6c4 with candidates 2 and 3; if cell r6c4 were not number 2, cell r9c4 would be forced to number 8, in turn, cell r4c9 to be number 8 and cell r6c5 to be number 8, therefore, regardless what number cell r6c4 has, cell r6c5 cannot be number 2.

What to notice: The key is the contradiction created by the chain. You are not guessing the value; you are testing a premise and showing what cannot exist.

Placeholder for a Nice Loop / AIC walkthrough screenshot

Walkthrough

Example 02 — Seeing both ends

Here is a five cells multi-number open ended chain; it looks like an XY-Chain or an X-Chain but instead of relying on shared number of bivalue cells or a single number, it uses strong and weak links with multiple numbers. The chain starts at cell r1c2, it is either number 4 or 5; if it were number 5, then cell r7c1 would be forced to number 5, in turn cell r8c1 would be forced to number 3, and cell r8c7 would be forced to number 4. Thereforce cell r8c2 cannot be 4 because cell r8c2 sees both chain ends r1c2 and r8c7 with number 4.

What to notice: X-Chain and XY-Chain are simply specialized variations of AIC.

Placeholder for a Nice Loop / AIC walkthrough screenshot

How it works

ALTERNATE THE LINKS, THEN READ WHAT THE END PROVES.

A strong link says that if one side is false, the other must be true. A weak link says that if one side is true, the other must be false. Alternating those implications through multiple numbers lets a premise travel around the chain. AICs use the same alternating logic even when the chain is not a simple named pattern.

01

Label the links.

For each caniddate connection, decide whether it is strong or weak. The chain must alternate. Remember a strong link is a special case of a weak link.

02

Follow the implication.

Read the candidates as an ON/OFF sequence. If one candidate is true, the next weak link turns off; a strong link can then force the next candidate on.

03

Read the endpoint.

When endpoint shares a number with the start, any cell sees both ends cannot have that number.

CHAIN 06

A useful reminder

THE LINK TYPES MATTER MORE THAN THE SHAPE.

AICs become much easier to understand when you stop looking for a picture and start reading the links. Every step must have a valid inference behind it.

Watch & learn

Watch live here.

Coming soon...

Practice

WRITE THE LINKS DOWN.

For early practice, annotate a candidate chain with strong and weak links before looking for the deduction. Once the alternating structure is clear, inspect the endpoints for the consequence.